New Scientific Study: BP Macondo Oil “…On the Bottom” Still

You remember the August 4, 2010 “Oil Budget” published by NOAA and the USGS that most of the oil spilled from BP’s Macondo well blowout had magically disappeared.  In a White House press conference held that day, retired Coast Guard Admiral Thad Allen did a victory lap that the leaking well was “static” and Jane Lubchenco joined in the happy talk saying that fish that had ingested oil would quickly rid themselves of that oil and soon be safe to eat.  Shortly after, respected scientist Terry Hazen of Berkeley National Labs published a report that microbes were quickly degrading the oil and that it would soon be gone.

Dead Sea Floor - Samantha Joye.jpgI believed at the time that all that happy talk was intended to calm public fears and get coverage of the largest environmental catastrophe in US history off of the television and out of the newspapers.  I also believed that the government was intentionally downplaying the damage to help BP stay afloat so they could pay out the $20 billion in damage payments that they had committed.   Some of my fears have now been confirmed.  An extensive new study, presented this weekend at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science by Samantha Joye of the University of Georgia has found that much of the oil from the Macondo well is still on the bottom of the Gulf and has killed much of the deepwater sea life in that area.  Joye’s study consisted of manned deepsea submersible trips and over 250 seafloor cores over 2,600 square miles of the Gulf. (Photo by the University of Georgia)

Joye said of the report, “Magic microbes consumed maybe 10 percent of the total discharge, the rest of it we don’t know; there’s a lot of it out there.”  Disputing oil spill czar Ken Feinberg’s assertion that the Gulf will be back to normal by next year, Joye told the Associated Press, “I’ve been to the bottom. I’ve seen what it looks like with my own eyes. It’s not going to be fine by 2012.  You see what the bottom looks like, you have a different opinion.”  Jane Lubchenco, director of NOAA who published the Happy Talk Report last August, though, is undeterred.  On Saturday, she said, “…it’s not a contradiction to say that although most of the oil is gone, there still remains oil out there.”

So.  We have a new, exhaustive report by academics that says the sea floor around the Macondo well is dead with a lot of oil on the bottom, yet we still have formerly respected scientists like Lubchenco, who now work for the government, issuing confusing, if not conficting statements claiming the contrary based on little, if any credible research.  And, in the midst of this continuing crisis, we see little to no interest from the media about the tragedy and destruction.  To my knowledge, this is the first rigorous study done of the sea floor that has been made public.  It’s not surprising that it directly contradicts the claims made by the US government over the last six months that everything in the Gulf is okey-dokey.

Of course, it’s not.  Far from it.


  1. WindorSolarPlease says

    You’re to late NOAA and USGS to announce this. People knew about this long ago. The sea floor is a mess, it’s a toxic soup.
    I don’t believe they down played this to calm the people, our officials are bought and paid by the corporate elites.
    If they cared, they would not have left the Gulf people hanging in the toxic wind, while they are losing their livelihood.
    Reporters on TV are told what to report, they are given a script. Who pays their salary. They were allowed to cover Egypt, but not allowed to cover the gulf like it should have been.
    These gulf problems are not over yet, the toxic soup is still there. Where there is oil, tar balls, tar mats, there is also toxic corexit, and who knows what else.
    Drilling is not the safest job and not the best for the environment. We are still dependant on oil, and they like it that way or else things would have changed long ago.
    Wasn’t that a sensitive area to drill in? Who knows what will happen next.
    One thing we have known for some time is: This toxic soup is still here and it is effecting so much, it won’t magically disappear.
    Has it magically stopped any flows completely, or are there cracks leaking?
    Could this disaster cause instability to other area’s?
    This area should not be forgotten or dropped, but researched and checked.
    The Public should be informed, this happened in our Country.
    They don’t want to put camera’s down there for people to watch, wonder why?
    This is the worst disaster that effects everyone, and they don’t want to spend money on it?
    I don’t believe they know how to handle this. I could not believe they ground those pieces of tar on the beach so fine that the tiny toxic particles are now floating in the air, wonder why people are getting sick?
    Their goal was to make the beach look nice, not for the safety of people.
    The Gulf and the people, are far from being okey-dokey.
    If there is a site that the public can watch the sea floor right now, please link it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

six × = 6

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>